Argument from Silence
I am often frustrated by arguments from silence. The following quote is an example of what is, to me, bewildering logic. The topic is the dating of James and the author would like to argue for an early dating by James the Just himself:
James’s lack of any mention of the destruction of Jerusalem in A.D. 70, though an argument from silence, does seem to support an early date. The destruction of Jerusalem was a highly significant event for the Jews. James, a Jewish author, writing to a Jewish audience, the twelve tribes who were dispersed (James 1:1), and writing a letter with Jewish concepts, would likely mention the destruction of Jerusalem, especially if he was writing after the city was destroyed. If James wrote after A.D. 70, some of his readers could have been present at the destruction of Jerusalem.
The letter of James also does not mention the life, death (possible and debatable exception is 5:11), or resurrection of Jesus. Presumably the author is writing after these events, which would have been important for the author’s audience. It seems to me that the life, death and resurrection of Jesus are quite a bit more relevant and more likely to be mentioned by the author than the destruction of the Temple in Jerusalem. By the way, Jerusalem itself was not destroyed in 70 CE, but the Temple was.
-

Like my blog on Facebook
About This Space
Welcome to the online abode for Patrick George McCullough, a student and educator of the New Testament and Christian origins. This is a place for questions, reflections, discussions, perhaps even some laughter. If you'd like to know a little more about me and my vision for this blog, take a gander at the About Pat page. Jump in the dialogue and peace be with you.
"The Levites . . . instructed the people in the Torah while the people were standing there. They read from the Book of the Torah of God, making it clear and giving the meaning so that the people could understand what was being read." (Neh 8:7-8)
On blogging etiquette, try to remember: "For all who exalt themselves will be humbled, and those who humble themselves will be exalted" (Luke 14:11). "Outdo one another in showing honor" (Romans 12:10).
Recent Comments
- Mark and Newer Methods « Euangelion Kata Markon on Theorizing Ourselves Past the Stale Pursuit of Authorial Intention
- I still don’t know the difference between a Bible scholar and a Biblical scholar… | BW16 on Bibliwho? What Should We Call Ourselves?
- Mhelfield on Theorizing Ourselves Past the Stale Pursuit of Authorial Intention
- Theorizing Ourselves Past the Stale Pursuit of Authorial Intention | kata ta biblia on Apocalypse against Empire: First Impressions and Opening Questions
- Steve Caruso on Bibliwho? What Should We Call Ourselves?
- Mhelfield on Apocalypse against Empire: First Impressions and Opening Questions
- Pat McCullough on Apocalypse against Empire: First Impressions and Opening Questions
Recent Tweets
- Does anyone have institutional access to the Early Christianity journal? Could you send this article along my way? http://t.co/tf9N8J0d 2 months ago
- My post on the UC Humanities Forum as a UC Humanities Correspondent: "The Study of Religion on UC Campuses" http://t.co/z50r0iWP #uchri 5 months ago
- @colemanbaker Saturday (19th), 1:00pm-3:30pm. #SBLAAR 6 months ago
- Don't forget to put my SAB panel on the "Future of Biblical Studies" (S19-242a) into your #SBLAAR schedule. It's going to be epic :) 6 months ago
- @SBLsite Thanks. Excellent news on the Abstracts! Will there be a PDF available of the program book? That would help w/ the problem #SBLAAR 6 months ago
- @SBLsite thanks for the update. Bummer. Glad to see you guys will have an active presence on the feed. Look forward to the FAQs. #SBLAAR 6 months ago
- #SBLAAR . . . That may present a problem scheduling those single paper drop-ins. Also, having abstracts would be nice. I don't see them. 6 months ago
Elsewhere . . .- Blog titles beginning with "A" to "Z" on your reader Mark Goodacre
- Of making many books there is no end Chris Brady
- Free Online: The Liddell-Scott Jones Lexicon S and C
- Does Higher Criticism Attempt to “Destroy the Bible”? II agathos
- Steven J. Friesen and the Identity of Satan’s Throne in Pergamum alan
- Does Higher Criticism Attempt to “Destroy the Bible”? agathos
- Bloomsbury buys Continuum Mark Goodacre
- Imperial America Peter J. Leithart
- C.F.D. Moule on the Birth of the New Testament d. miller
- Responding to Kostenberger (with comparisons to Marshall) Jeremiah
A Few Good Blogs
- Ancient Hebrew Poetry (John Hobbins)
- Biblioblogs.com
- Café Apocalypsis (Alan Bandy)
- Chrisendom (Chris Tilling)
- Clayboy (Doug Chaplin)
- Coleman Baker
- Dr. Jim West
- Emerging Women
- Euangelion (Bird & Willitts)
- Exploring Our Matrix (James F. McGrath)
- Forbidden Gospels Blog (April DeConick)
- Higgaion (Chris Heard)
- Jesus and Empire (Rob Reid)
- Julia O'Brien
- Katagrapho (D. Christopher Spinks)
- Ketuvim (Jim Getz)
- nijay k gupta
- NTGeeks (Greg Carey)
- Paul of Tarsus in Historical Context (Kevin Scull)
- Religions of the Ancient Mediterranean (Phil Harland)
- Sitz im Leben (Brandon Wason)
- The Busybody (Loren Rosson)
- The Golden Rule (Mike Kok)
- The Milk Mama (Christina — My Wife)
Less Recent Thoughts



